Living Room Carpet Vs Laminate
Raymond R. James
October 13, 2021
So you’re getting a new floor.So to make it easier, we’re going to compare the two flooring materials side by side—comparing their construction, installation method, durability, best uses, maintenance, and cost—to help figure out which one is the right floor for you.Carpet vs. laminate construction.That’s because flooring manufacturers are developing new styles and materials every single day, and the only way to really stay ahead of the curve is to talk to someone in your area who sells flooring professionally.Depending on the material, this generally makes cut pile the softer of the bunch and loop pile the most durable.What is laminate flooring?Finally, laminate has a top wear layer to protect it from damage.While it depends on the specific product and materials you’re using, carpet and laminate can both be extremely durable flooring choices.Loop pile is generally more durable than cut or cut-and-loop pile (which is often used to make patterned carpets).Thanks to its hard wear layer, laminate’s can be extremely durable.When it comes to construction and durability, the pros and cons of laminate and carpet are almost entirely based on which specific brand and product you buy.Installing carpet.Generally speaking, carpet needs to be installed by a professional (and a good one at that).And yes: carpet is probably going to be more of a hassle to install than it would be to install some other types of flooring due to the necessity of having a skilled professional, but trust us—it’s worth it.Installing laminate.It’s usually sold as click-together flooring, meaning it’s composed of interlocking planks that don’t require any nails or glue to install.This also makes it a “floating floor”—meaning it can be put in directly on top of existing surfaces (again, because there are no glue or nails necessary).Of course, you can also install underlayments below laminate if you’re so inclined.Certain laminate products even require it, whereas some types of laminate already come with an underlayment layer below the base.What are the best uses for carpet and laminate?Think about going with a wool cut pile.If you need something waterproof, we’d recommend looking into the pros and cons of tile vs.
laminate.These days, you can actually buy snap-together tile flooring, which is almost as easy to install as click-together laminate!Go with laminate.Laminate.And you can always get in touch with a flooring dealer in your area to find direct quotes.What are you looking for in a floor? .
2020 Carpet vs Hardwood Floors: Cost, Resale Value, Installation
Carpet comes in a great variety of colors, styles, textures and thickness.It is a good insulator and even muffles sound, which is why many homeowners and renters still prefer it in their bedrooms.Hardwood is usually ¾ inches thick and there are many species available for different budgets and aesthetic tastes.Not only is it available in a variety of colors; carpet comes with options for fiber or pile so you can zero in on the most appropriate type for your home.Fiber Type Cost per Square Foot Description NYLON $1.00 – $6.50 Most common.These options range greatly in hardness, grain, color and price.Species Cost per Square Foot Description MAPLE $3.50 – $6.00 One of the most common options.The main determining price factors are the fibers, type of pile and square footage involved.If you’re thinking of tackling your project without a pro, there are several factors to consider.Cons Can be difficult if working with multiple rooms, poor subfloor conditions or oddly shaped spaces.If you’re planning to sell within the next 10 years, resale value can play a big role in your decision.Carpet This option hasn’t completely lost favor with home buyers and is still king with older generations.New installations do not tend to affect resale value either way, but homes with old carpet will certainly suffer in the market.The report also estimates that this project has an average return on investment of 91 percent.If you’re looking for the longest-term investment and you’re not interested in replacing your flooring within the next 20 years, there is a clear winner in the durability category.Carpet Pros This material is a bit more breathable and can withstand a certain level of moisture.Cons Fibers can trap and grow mold if left moist for prolonged periods.As a result, only install it on the ground floor and upper levels as opposed to the basement.Cons More difficult to maintain because it shows dirt and stains easily.Needs a deep clean every couple of years to maintain peak appearance.Hardwood Pros Easy to clean, maintain and repair.Growing options for renewable and sustainable remodeling materials, help make our homes greener and more environmentally friendly.In fact, as it breaks down, it tends to release volatile organic compounds.The Forest Stewardship Council oversees the harvesting practices and environmental impact of lumber producers in the United States and Canada.Cons Looped piles can snag your pet’s nails.Stains, dirt and pet dander will be prevalent, obvious and difficult to clean.Hardwood Pros The most durable types, like maple and oak, do not scratch easily.You’ll need to take proactive steps to maintain hardwood with pets in the home.It grips onto dust, mildew and pet dander, and you’ll need to deep-clean more regularly if allergies are an issue.Hardwood is better for those with allergies because it is easy to clean and doesn’t grab onto allergens.It can be a great home modification, but which material works best, and which potentially negates its effectiveness?Soft and dense boards not good over radiant heating because temperature changes cause them to fluctuate (expand, contract).Carpet is best for… Hardwood is best for… DIY Installers Resale Value Smaller Budgets Durability Bedrooms Radiant Heating Low-Traffic Rooms Sustainability Muffling Sound Living Rooms Those who prefer soft flooring Maintenance & Repair.First, they are easier to clean—a great trait for some of the busiest rooms in the home.Second, these are the rooms where buyers want to see that in-demand material and where it can greatly help your resale value.Carpet, on the other hand, would muffle those high-traffic sounds and make for a safer stairway.You or your professional should also be sure to prep the subfloor (concrete) in order to minimize moisture.It traps moisture, dirt and spills and will be difficult to maintain.You can install hardwood in the kitchen, but it must have a sealant that protects it against the moisture in the space.As you work with professionals, be sure to discuss whether or not they have included removal in their total quote.They are available in tiles that look like wooden planks and create a unique aesthetic, and there are larger “photorealistic” wood options as well.Expect to pay closer to $2 – $12 per square foot for professional installation and materials.Many renters are interested in this option, as they can easily remove the product when their lease is up.Can be very cold underfoot; isn’t preferable in bedrooms and living rooms.If you’re updating your flooring for yourself, ceramic tiles are a great economic option. .
9 Reasons The “Carpet vs. Hardwood” Debate is Silly
In fact, when you think of carpeting, you probably picture an old-fashioned ‘70s shag that smells like musty basement.Like so many other types of flooring, carpet has come a long way in recent years in terms of durability, hypoallergenic qualities, and stain resistance.That’s why today, we’re going to discuss 9 reasons why the carpet vs. hardwood debate is ridiculous—and why either one is a great choice!When shopping, ask your local flooring people about different finishes and wear layer options so you can find the right match for your lifestyle needs.Most hardwood options are water-resistant and will tolerate a lot of life’s messy matters.Reason #2: Carpet and hardwood both offer a ton of installation methods.If you’re going the DIY route, grab some carpet tiles from Amazon or Home Depot and go to town!Click-together or “snap-lock” planks are installed as floating floors, which can be more DIY-friendly since they don’t need to be attached to a subfloor.Our advice: before you break out the knee pads, look into the advantages and disadvantages of floating floors.Look for products made from organic materials like wool, cotton, or bamboo.Some companies even use reclaimed and recycled materials to construct carpet products.In fact, when talking about the pros and cons of engineered bamboo flooring, sustainability tops the list.You’ve got endless patterns and colors with tiles or broadloom carpet.The millions of color, fiber, and texture options range all the way from New York Times-approved plush purple chic to Bob Vila-beloved subtle suggestions.And don’t forget all the types of fiber: nylon, wool, polyester, olefin, triexta—the list goes on.And of course, this discussion MUST circle back to the awesomeness of carpet tile with its bazillion potential combos of colors and patterns.Fun Fact: tiles can be arranged as an area rug over all sorts of existing flooring.Hardwood gives you a million combinations too—wood species, cut patterns, finishes, etc.There are dozens of wood species to choose from—oak, mahogany, walnut, bamboo, and cork to name a few—and each one offers its own unique look and feel.Well, literally speaking, that the installation method can affect a floor’s feel.A floating floor may have more give as you walk vs. solid planks that are nailed to the underlayment.But we think grandma was also talking about the lovely ripples and texture of that top layer of traditional hardwood floors—which can still be enjoyed with numerous cuts, finishes, and even some recycled wood floor options.Reason #6: Carpet vs.
Hardwood costs totally depend on your choices.But there are so many options on the market, the carpet vs. hardwood cost debate totally depends on what you choose!Carpet cost will run you between $2–$12 per square foot (on average) depending on the brand, style, density, fiber, and padding you choose.Hardwood cost also has a wide range in price depending on the quality of the product, tree species, and installation method you choose.Either way, contact your local flooring dealer to get a more accurate idea of your carpet vs.
hardwood costs.It’s also worth mentioning that solid hardwood can be sanded and refinished many times, which bumps it up in the durability department.In this case, you can have your cake and eat it too by adding carpet tiles to any hardwood surface you like!If you’re selling your home and don’t want to invest in new wood floors, fresh, NEW carpet can bring a sense of cozy charm and versatility to a potential buyer.A local flooring expert near you can help you choose a carpet within your budget to appeal to your target audience.Okay, so you probably don’t need a “how stuff works” guide to vacuuming your hypothetical new carpet. .
Carpet vs Laminate Flooring - Difference and Comparison
Carpet, which is made from wool or a synthetic fiber, such as polypropylene, nylon, or polyester, is attached to a backing that is generally nailed or stapled to the floor and any padding underneath.One layer of laminate flooring is dedicated to a photographic appliqué that generally imitates wood and sometimes stone.Laminate flooring is considered more hygienic and hypoallergenic than carpet, as it is easily cleaned, and dirt won't go unnoticed.Carpet tends to retain dust and pollen, stain more easily, and build up mold and mildew when exposed to moisture, making it a less desirable option for those who struggle with allergies.All styles have an upper layer of pile – the frilly, soft yarns that stand up on the flooring — attached to a backing.Laminate tends to come in designs mimicking natural flooring options, such as wood and stone, and the range of colors, patterns, and piles of carpet available are almost limitless.Laminate flooring tends to provide a more versatile base for interior decorating due to its resemblance to natural products.Bright or decorative carpets may suit one's style now, but might be difficult to incorporate into new décor choices in the future.A Lumber Liquidators' survey found that 100% of real estate agents polled preferred hardwood floors to carpet.However, as laminate flooring is typically more stylish, easier to maintain, and longer lasting, it is more likely to improve the resale value of the home than carpeting.More expensive laminate flooring is often a better investment, though carpet provides a cheaper option should users wish to renovate more frequently.Modern carpeting is more durable and stain-resistant than in the past, but it's generally accepted that it won't last more than 10 years in any areas with moderate traffic.Carpet and padding are first trimmed to the correct dimensions, and then the two layers are installed with nails or staples, and seams are glued down.Leaving pools of water to stand will damage laminate flooring and carpet, both of which may then require replacement.Users should place protective pads on the bottoms of chair and table legs to prevent scratching.Laminate flooring offers the advantage that small sections can be replaced, as needed, to repair damages.Laminate works better if you are a landlord and need flooring options for your rental property because carpets tend to show more wear and stains from mud and liquid spills.While some may prefer the warmth and comfort of carpets, the advantages of using laminate flooring in the living room include:.In an overview of the science on public health and housing conditions, James Krieger of the University of Washington and Donna L. Higgins of the CDC point out that old carpeting can aggravate allergy symptoms, as the fibers catch and hold dirt, allergens, pesticides, and toxic chemicals.The Center for Health Design's review of research notes that though some studies point to carpet being vulnerable to fungi and bacteria contamination, the results are conflicting.Vacuuming a new carpet with a HEPA filter vac and using hot water extraction cleaners can help remove VOCs.
Carpet vs Laminate
Carpet vs Laminate.But you’re still here because as different as carpet and laminate are they both make great floors.And maybe more importantly, they both make great value floors—meaning they don’t come with a crazy luxury price tag (more on that later).So when it comes down to it, which is better for your home—carpet or laminate?Actually, I take most pride in Carpet Captain the internet’s unbiased flooring guide–I don’t sell flooring, so I’m not influenced by the profit margins of one product vs another.Actually, I take most pride in Carpet Captain the internet’s unbiased flooring guide–I don’t sell flooring, so I’m not influenced by the profit margins of one product vs another.Both low-quality carpet and laminate can last you less than 3 years.Most quality carpets and laminate floors will last 8 to 15 years.Most laminate can be easily snapped into place, so removing a tile and inserting a new one is a DIY job.Carpet repairs require a professional.Installing a laminate floor can be a one day project if you don’t have any setbacks.If you’re still interested, this is a pretty good article on what it takes to install laminate.Can’t blame you because no matter how “affordable” your flooring is, you’re still investing in a big home improvement project.I don’t like doing it, but I have to give price for these two floors a tie.Laminate picks up another slight win here, but you’ll appreciate that both floors don’t require much in the maintenance department.Carpet requires a professional deep cleaning every one to two years.One benefit is it insulates your home.This makes it one of the few flooring types that makes your home more energy efficient.You’ll also have a quieter home with carpet.Or worse, the installation is starting to split.Some people are disappointed by their carpet’s durability, but they usually bought the wrong product.Learning what makes a carpet durable avoids 90% of these cases.Carpet vs Laminate in the basement.Now, while I covered the main characteristics of laminate and carpet floorings, there’s one section of most homes that needs to get a special mention as well – the basement.There’s one problem with basements no matter what type of flooring you install: moisture.If you have a moisture problem but still need new flooring, carpet is probably your better of the two.The most obvious example is laminate is your only option of the two in the kitchen, but carpet gives you the warmth and softness that is appreciated in a kids room or living room.But I also like to mix in some rooms with carpet for its insulation, sound dampening and warmer, “homey” feel.Looking into the future, I don’t think either will make a big difference in your home value. .
Carpet vs Laminate Flooring Comparison Guide
When it comes to making the choice about carpet vs laminate, finding the right solution for your home depends on your specific needs and requirements. .
The Best Flooring to Increase Home Value
Carpet vs. Laminate for Resale Value.Is Laminate the Best Flooring to Increase Home Value?Today, this type of flooring isn't quite as popular as it used to be in the eyes of new homeowners.High-end carpet with a low pile and a trendy neutral color can still add decent resale value to your home.If you choose a quality laminate, you'll likely get a decent return on your investment.Make sure the laminate floors are in pristine condition and that they're in a versatile color that works with a variety of decor and furniture.While new styles of luxury laminate flooring look beautiful, hardwood tends to be the best flooring to increase home value.With a high-quality laminate floor, buyers might not even be able to tell the difference between this material and hardwood at first glance.If you want something a bit more high-end than laminate but less expensive than hardwood, try luxury vinyl plank flooring.Luxury vinyl plank floors can mimic real wood with unique grain patterns and veining.